Fitness Apps are Not Beneficial For You but Why?

In the age of smartphones and technology, fitness enthusiasts have access to a plethora of fitness applications, or "apps" that claim to help individuals achieve and maintain their personal fitness goals. Fitness apps have gained immense popularity in recent years, with a significant portion of smartphone and tablet owners using them to track their health and fitness goals. But are they truly beneficial, or are they just another digital distraction? Despite their widespread use, many users find themselves dissatisfied with these apps over time. In this article, we will explore the reasons why people hate fitness apps and discuss ways to improve them for a better user experience.

The Rise of Fitness Apps on a Double Edged Sword

Over the past decade, the use of fitness apps has skyrocketed. These apps offer a myriad of features, ranging from step tracking to heart rate monitoring, and they have attracted millions of users worldwide. According to a Pew Research Center survey a staggering 69% of adults track health indicators using these apps. The fitness app may seem like a convenient tool but it's essential to examine their true impact on our health and privacy.

The Study of Assessing Adherence and Effectiveness for Fitness Apps

A study conducted over a 5-month period examined the usage, adherence, and effectiveness of three fitness apps . The study initially included 64 participants who downloaded three free apps available on Android and iOS platforms. By the end of the study, 47 participants remained, providing valuable insights into the long-term usage and impact of fitness apps. The study utilized a one-group pre posttest design and assessed exercise and exercise with fitness apps within the framework of the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) using a validated survey.

Read More: Is Period Pain Relief Belt Effective ?

The Theory of Planned Behavior in the Context of Fitness Apps

The Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) is a relevant theoretical framework to understand the relationship between technology and health behaviors. TPB explores the constructs of attitude, subjective norm, perceived behavioral control and behavioral intention, all of which contribute to behavior change. In the case of fitness apps, attitude refers to beliefs about using apps for exercise, subjective norm pertains to the influence of peers on exercise, perceived behavioral control examines the control and barriers associated with exercising with apps, and behavioral intention measures the likelihood of engaging in exercise using apps. By applying TPB to the study, researchers sought to understand how these constructs are impacted by app usage and if they contribute to behavior change.

Is the Promise of Weight Loss Really a Fact or Fiction?

One of the most common claims made by fitness apps is their ability to aid in weight loss. Numerous studies have analyzed the effectiveness of these apps, and the results are mixed. A meta analysis of 41 studies found that individuals who used mobile fitness apps experienced a significant drop in their body mass index (BMI) compared to those who didn't use the apps. This finding suggests that these apps may indeed be helpful for weight loss. However, it's important to note that successful weight loss strategies are multifaceted and require a holistic approach beyond just using an app.

The Dark Side of Fitness App for Unhealthy Obsession and Eating Disorders

While fitness apps may have positive effects on weight loss, they also have a darker side. Research has shown that individuals who use fitness apps are more likely to engage in disordered eating behaviors. Specifically, young, college-educated women, who are already at a higher risk for developing eating disorders, are particularly susceptible to using these apps. The constant focus on numbers, such as calorie counting and exercise tracking, can foster rigid, inflexible thinking and perfectionistic tendencies. This can lead to feelings of guilt and anxiety when goals are not met, perpetuating unhealthy behaviors.

Read More: Effective Ways to Use Heat Therapy for Lower Back Pain Relief

Why not Fitness Apps are very Beneficial?

Fitness apps are beneficial for many individuals as they provide various features and tools to track and monitor fitness goals, nutrition and workouts. 

1. Lack of Personalization: Fitness apps often provide generic workouts and nutrition plans that may not be tailored to an individual's specific needs and preferences. This lack of personalization can make it challenging for some users to stick with the app or achieve their desired results.

2. Inaccurate Tracking: While fitness apps aim to track activities such as steps, calories burned, and heart rate, they may not always provide accurate measurements. Pedometers, for example, may only estimate step counts loosely, leading to potential inaccuracies in tracking progress. This can be frustrating for users who rely on accurate data for their fitness goals.

3. Dependency on Technology: Some individuals may become overly reliant on fitness apps and lose touch with their own intuition and body signals. Relying solely on app recommendations and metrics may hinder the development of a healthy relationship with exercise and nutrition.

4. Mental Health Concerns: For individuals with a history of disordered eating or body image issues, fitness apps that focus on tracking calories or promoting specific body ideals can be triggering and detrimental to their mental health. These apps may exacerbate negative thoughts and behaviors related to food and body image.

5. Lack of Motivation and Accountability: While fitness apps can provide motivation through goal-setting and progress tracking, some individuals may struggle to stay motivated without the support of a real-life coach or community. Without the accountability and guidance of a human trainer, it can be challenging to maintain consistency and long-term adherence to fitness goals.

6. The Limitations of Calorie Counting: One of the main features of fitness apps is their ability to track calorie intake and expenditure. However, counting calories alone is often deemed too simplistic and ineffective in achieving long-term health and weight goals. While it is true that maintaining an energy balance is important, there are other factors at play. For instance, certain medications can cause weight gain or loss by altering hormone levels in the body. This highlights the fact that not all calories are created equal. Fitness apps should take into account the quality of calories consumed and their impact on overall health.

Read More: “Yoga” The All Natural Solution to Banish Back Pain | The Benefits of Yoga for Back Pain Relief

7. The Need for Automation: Tracking every morsel of food consumed can be tedious and time-consuming. Many fitness apps rely on manual input from users, requiring them to log their meals and activities daily. This lack of automation leads to user frustration and ultimately contributes to app abandonment. To address this issue, fitness apps should incorporate features that allow for quicker input of required information. By streamlining the process, users are more likely to continue using the app in the long run.

8. Battery Drainage Woes:  Another common complaint among fitness app users is the excessive battery usage these apps require. Constantly tracking activity and connecting to wearable devices can quickly drain a smartphone's battery. This poses a significant inconvenience, especially for users who engage in longer workout sessions or outdoor activities. Developers should focus on optimizing the app's energy consumption to minimize battery drainage and provide a seamless user experience.

9. GPS Inaccuracy: Many fitness apps offer GPS tracking features to monitor running routes and compare performance. However, the accuracy of these GPS calculations can often be questionable. Users may find that the app miscalculates their routes, leading to inaccurate data on calories burned and other metrics. This discrepancy can significantly impact a user's motivation and trust in the app. Developers should prioritize improving GPS connectivity and accuracy to ensure users have reliable data to track their progress.

10. The Importance of Community Support: Lack of community support is a major drawback of fitness apps. Studies have shown that having a support system is crucial for sustaining lifestyle changes, such as adopting a healthier diet or increasing physical activity. While some apps offer social sharing features, they often fall short in fostering an active and supportive community. To address this issue, developers should focus on creating interactive platforms that encourage users to connect, share their progress, and provide support to one another.

11. Overwhelming Amounts of Data: Fitness apps often bombard users with an overwhelming amount of data related to health and fitness. This information overload can be confusing and discouraging, making it difficult for users to extract actionable insights. To improve user experience, app creators should prioritize curating and presenting relevant information in a clear and understandable manner. By narrowing down the data to what truly matters, users can easily grasp the information and make informed decisions about their health.

12. The Pitfalls of Gamification: Many fitness apps rely on gamification techniques to motivate users. By incorporating game-like incentives such as points, badges, and leaderboard scores, these apps aim to encourage specific behaviors. However, relying solely on gamification may lead to short-term engagement and eventually result in user boredom and disinterest. To address this issue, fitness apps should shift their focus to helping users find enjoyment in the activity itself, rather than solely relying on extrinsic rewards. By fostering a genuine love for physical activity, users are more likely to sustain their fitness journey.

13. Privacy Concerns on Exposing More Than Your Workouts: In addition to potential mental health risks, fitness apps also pose significant privacy concerns. These apps collect an extensive amount of personal data, including your location, exercise habits, and even sensitive health information. While some apps claim to anonymize or de-identify this data, studies have shown that it is possible to re-identify individuals based on their exercise patterns and locations. This raises serious questions about the security and privacy practices of these apps. With data breaches becoming increasingly common, the risk of having your personal information exposed to malicious actors is a genuine concern.

14. The Truth Behind the Hype of Unveiling the Limitations: Despite the promises made by fitness apps, it's crucial to recognize their limitations. While they can provide valuable information and motivation, they are not a magical solution for achieving optimal health. Let's explore some of the key limitations of these apps.

15. Lack of Personalization for One Size Does Not Fit All: One of the main shortcomings of fitness apps is their lack of customization. Many of these apps provide generalized recommendations based on age, height, and weight, without considering individual differences and specific health needs. This cookie-cutter approach may not be suitable for everyone and can lead to ineffective or even harmful fitness routines. True behavioral change requires personalized guidance and tailored strategies to ensure long term success.

Read More: Hollow Body Holds vs. Crunches: Which is Better for Your Core?

16. Lack of Scientific Basis of Marketing vs Evidence Based Approach: Many fitness apps on the market today lack a solid scientific foundation. App developers, often without backgrounds in health or psychology, may rely on marketing strategies rather than evidence-based practices. This disconnect between app developers and behavioral scientists can result in apps that are not grounded in sound behavioral change theories. To ensure the efficacy of these apps, it is essential for developers to collaborate with experts in the field and incorporate evidence-based strategies into their design.

The Results Considering Insights into App Usage and Effectiveness

The results of the study revealed several key findings regarding app usage and effectiveness. Individual item scores indicated no significant change pre to posttest, except for decreases observed in the usefulness of using apps for exercise, peer influence on exercise, peer influence on exercise with apps, perceived difficulties in exercising with apps, and the expected frequency of exercise with apps over the next 2 weeks. These findings suggest that participants perceived the apps to be less useful over time and experienced decreased peer influence, indicating that social support did not play a significant role in exercise behavior with or without the apps.

Subscale total scores indicated significant decreases in subjective norm regarding exercise, subjective norm regarding exercise with apps, and perceived behavioral control over exercising with apps between pre and posttest. This implies that participants' beliefs about the importance of peers for exercise weakened over time, and they found it more difficult to exercise using the apps. Interestingly, when comparing app users to non-users, there was only a significant difference in the attitude toward exercising using apps at posttest, with users having a more favorable attitude. Fitness perception did not change significantly over the 5-month study period regarding cardiovascular fitness, strength, endurance, flexibility, or body composition. This suggests that app usage did not have a significant impact on participants' perception of their own fitness levels.

Implications for App Development and Usage

The findings of this study shed light on the factors that influence app usage and effectiveness. The study also highlighted the issue of technology usage attrition, with a desirable attrition rate of 31.9%. This suggests that participants who stopped using the apps continued to participate in the study, providing valuable insights into the differences between app users and non-users. Further research is needed to better understand technology attrition and its impact on study outcomes.

Read More: 10 Exercises to Strengthen Your Lower Back at Home

Conclusion

While fitness apps offer convenience and a wide range of features, their effectiveness in promoting long-term behavior change remains uncertain. The study discussed in this article provides insights into the adherence and effectiveness of fitness apps, emphasizing the importance of app usefulness, ease of use, and the need for theory-based interventions. As technology continues to evolve, it’s a valuable tool for tracking your workouts, monitoring progress, and gaining motivation. Strive for a balanced approach to fitness, incorporating a variety of strategies and seeking professional guidance when needed. 

"If you have a fitness goal in mind, there are endless apps out there designed to help you achieve it" 

 - Huma Khurshid